lawrence avenue tacos al pastor

At most restaurants that serve tacos al pastor in Chicago, you get chopped pork that's griddled with chile powder and topped with onions and cilantro. At other places, you get the real thing and transcend your body into pork paradise.

As a meat junkie from way back, I prefer the latter version. It typically involves cuts of chile-marinated pork that are stacked in layers and topped with a pineapple on a vertical broiler. The pineapple is key because its enzymes tenderize the meat as it slowly rotates in the broiler. The cook might also include pieces of the pineapple as he shaves the meat. The result is a delicate if not startling fruitiness in what's otherwise a hardcore meat dish. My all-time al pastor place--the long-closed El Nopal near Clark and Bryn Mawr--took it a step further by putting extra pineapple with the layers of pork on the broiler, ensuring that every taco got a little bit of fruit during the shaving process. I've looked but have yet to find a taqueria that does al pastor quite like this. Most places just throw a lemon or lime on the side and figure that's enough fruit for one dish.

The term al pastor means "shepherd-style." In the same wandering spirit, I've spent many an afternoon searching taqueria after taqueria, hoping to find an al pastor taco like I used to know. The mixed results from my latest three-mile journey along Lawrence Avenue are documented below.

Carmelita's
Carmelita's
1206 W. Lawrence Ave.
TASTE:
PRESENTATION: AMBIENCE:
Carmelita's al pastor tacos are highly edible but comparatively mundane to the enormous rotisserie that greets patrons inside the door. Almost all the cooking takes place on the griddle and little if any pineapple usually makes it into the tortilla.

Lindo Guadalupana
Lindo Guadalupena
4764 N. Clark St.
TASTE:
PRESENTATION: AMBIENCE:
Heavily seasoned and prepared entirely on a griddle, Lindo Guadalupana's al pastor is tender and lean. Good for a quick fix, they're probably not something to order in multiple doses.



Taqueria Uptown
Taqueria Uptown
1708 W. Lawrence Ave.
TASTE:
PRESENTATION: AMBIENCE:
Initially cooked on the spit and then finished on the griddle, the over-portioned meat here has more fat and less seasoning than its peers; more like a chopped up pork cutlet than shepherd-style.


Taco Loco
Taco Loco
1726 W. Lawrence Ave.
TASTE:
PRESENTATION: AMBIENCE:
Taco Loco's lean and tender cuts of al pastor literally drip with flavor. There's no pineapple and no rotisserie, but whatever's going on in the kitchen seems to be working.


Garcias #2
Garcia's #2
1758 W. Lawrence Ave.
TASTE:
PRESENTATION: AMBIENCE:
The smaller of the two sister restaurants in Lincoln Square, Garcia's #2 al pastor comes without a lime and almost no seasoning. Though tastey, the meat is far from the Mexican delicacy decribed on the menu.

Peralvillo
Peralvillo
1969 W. Lawrence Ave.
TASTE:
PRESENTATION: AMBIENCE:
Peralvillo's broiler is within eyeshot of the seating area but it's usually unused. Still, the griddled meat, mingled with bits of carmelized onions, is always pleasingly moist and spicey.


Taco Place
Taco Place
2114 W. Lawrence Ave.
TASTE:
PRESENTATION: AMBIENCE:
Served with neither pineapple, lime nor lemon, Taco Place's al pastor tacos contain wide, well-done cuts of meat that are pretty bland. Next time I'll stick with the steak.


Dos Picantes
Dos Picantes
3119 W. Lawrence Ave.
TASTE:
PRESENTATION: AMBIENCE:
If not for the digital photo in my camera, I'd have forgotten all about this mundane little number.



Garcias #1
Garcia's
4749 N. Western Ave.
TASTE:
PRESENTATION: AMBIENCE:
If there's any love in Garcia's kitchen, it's reserved more for the time clock than the wheel of meat. The food here, regardless of the dish, invariably comes out like the cooks have something better to do.

Santa Rita
Santa Rita
2752 W. Lawrence Ave.
TASTE:
PRESENTATION: AMBIENCE:
There's no pineapple, but the tender al pastor here comes off the spit so full of mouthwatering flavors that its hard to have just one.


San Matias
San Matias
3005 W. Lawrence Ave.
TASTE:
PRESENTATION: AMBIENCE:
San Matias' al pastor is tender, a little fatty, and not nearly as endearing as the fancy radish and cucumber garnish on the side.


Las Huaraches
Huaraches
3021 W. Lawrence Ave.
TASTE:
PRESENTATION: AMBIENCE:
Though it specializes in handmade versions of its namesake dish, Huaraches serves a decent taco al pastor. This one came out a just little overdone.

Lindo Michoacan
Lindo Michoacan
3148 W. Lawrence Ave.
TASTE:
PRESENTATION: AMBIENCE:
Served with tastey chunks of charred pineapple, Lindo Michoacan's al pastor would be the real deal if it was cooked on a rotisserie. Regardless, the tacos are delish.

Los Faroles
Los Faroles
3149 W. Lawrence Ave.
TASTE:
PRESENTATION: AMBIENCE:
Loosely translated, Los Faroles means "the lanterns" but there's nothing enlightening here. The tacos are plain, fatty and altogether lackluster.

Los Pinos
Los Pinos
3209 W. Lawrence Ave.
TASTE:
PRESENTATION: AMBIENCE:
The bright lights in this unassuming taqueria provide a good look at all the seasoning that got dumped on the meat while it was griddling. Nothing special.

The Winner